Dear Mr. Yusupov,
In relation to your above-referenced PCT application, we have the following comments.
Our understanding is that you disagree with the findings of the United States Patent Office (USPTO), acting as an International Searching Authority (ISA), and that you request WIPO to assess the legality of the ISA’s findings and to replace the (findings of) the ISA.
Under the PCT, the International Bureau of WIPO does not have any oversight function in relation to the international search procedure, any delays thereof or the contents of any international search reports. In particular, the PCT Contracting States have not provided the International Bureau with any mandate to modify or replace the results of an international search.
Any issues or concerns relating to the contents of any particular international search results should be raised directly with the ISA concerned. Under the PCT legal and procedural framework, each ISA is required to have in place a system for monitoring and using customer feedback, including an appropriate system for handling complaints and for taking corrective action where necessary. We therefore advise you to make use of the appropriate mechanism at the USPTO to communicate your views concerning the findings of the ISA.
It should also be kept in mind that the International Search Report and the written opinion are non-binding and that each designated Office will decide upon the patentability of the invention under its specific law in the national phase. Once you enter the national phase, you may of course communicate your views to be taken into account by the technical experts in the particular designated Offices during their own independent analysis under their applicable national or regional law.
I hope that this information is helpful to you.
Eva Schumm, Senior Legal Officer,
Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT) Legal and User Support Section,




